In a move that has ignited heated debate across social media, ADOR — the HYBE subsidiary label behind NewJeans — shared anniversary content for the group's 4th debut anniversary on July 22, 2026. The tribute, featuring group photos and messages, has been widely criticized by fans (known as Bunnies) who view it as an insincere public relations effort amid a prolonged legal battle and unresolved creative disputes.
 |
| ADOR |
NewJeans, who debuted in 2022 with massive hits that reshaped K-pop trends, have been largely inactive for over a year due to contract termination attempts and court injunctions. Fans have accused the label and its parent company HYBE of prioritizing corporate control over artist welfare, especially following the high-profile exit of former ADOR CEO Min Hee-jin, who played a key role in the group's distinctive Y2K-inspired, youthful concept.
Fan Backlash: "Stop the Fake Affection"
Social media platforms erupted with frustration shortly after the posts went live. Many fans called the tribute hypocritical, pointing to the label's legal actions that have restricted the members' independent activities. Comments like "Stop this fake display of affection" and accusations of treating the group as a "dead horse" for PR purposes have trended.
One recurring theme is the perception that ADOR and HYBE are using milestone celebrations to strengthen their position in ongoing lawsuits while allegedly failing to support the artists' creative autonomy. Critics argue this reflects broader issues in the industry where powerful agencies exert heavy influence, sometimes at the expense of the talent that built their success. Supporters of the members have expressed disappointment that a group once hailed for its fresh, authentic vibe now appears caught in corporate power struggles.
[NewJeans Day]
— NewJeans (@NewJeans_ADOR) July 21, 2026
🐰#NewJeans #뉴진스#NewJeansDay #NewJeans_4th_Anniversary pic.twitter.com/llZtz2y076
Spotlight on Danielle's Separate Message
The controversy deepened with member Danielle's independent Instagram update, which stood in contrast to the group's official tribute. Absent from the main anniversary video featuring Minji, Hanni, Haerin, and Hyein, Danielle shared personal photos accompanied by a reflective caption: “Life gets cloudy sometimes, but the light always finds its way back in. Until then, keep shining. Forever grateful.”
Fans interpreted the post as a subtle acknowledgment of ongoing difficulties and uncertainty surrounding her status with ADOR. It fueled speculation about differing paths among the members, with some viewing Danielle's message as a quiet expression of resilience amid the turmoil. Discussions highlighted how the anniversary highlighted not just label-artist tensions but also potential divisions within the group itself, adding emotional weight to the fanbase's frustrations.
Danielle via Instagram
— About NewJeans (@AboutMusicNWJNS) July 21, 2026
“Life gets cloudy sometimes, but the light always finds its way back in✨
Until then, keep shining
Forever grateful,
Dazzi xx” pic.twitter.com/PCIfaICgXK
The ILLIT Controversy and Producer Involvement
The anniversary backlash is inseparable from lingering accusations surrounding HYBE's girl group ILLIT (under Belift Lab). Former ADOR leadership and many fans have long claimed that ILLIT's debut concept, styling, choreography, and promotional materials bore striking similarities to NewJeans' signature aesthetic. Court documents and internal reports have fueled discussions, with some evidence suggesting shared planning influences or references, though labels have denied outright plagiarism and courts have reached mixed conclusions on the specifics.
HYBE Chairman Bang Si-hyuk has been directly involved as a producer for ILLIT, adding another layer to the scrutiny. Observers note that while inspiration is common in entertainment, the timing and extent of overlaps raised legitimate questions about creative ethics and fair competition within the same corporate family. Fans argue that such situations can dilute a pioneering group's uniqueness and create unnecessary fatigue for all involved artists — including ILLIT members, who have also faced fan wars not of their own making.
Industry watchers suggest this highlights systemic challenges at large entertainment conglomerates like HYBE: balancing multiple acts under one umbrella while protecting individual group identities. Allegations of uneven support or concept borrowing have persisted despite official denials, contributing to eroded trust among fandoms.
Oh it’s so over https://t.co/DVpMMxAEOJ pic.twitter.com/6VM9rnxiik
— sofi🐇 (@haerinlune) July 22, 2026
Calls for Accountability Without Easy Escapes
While opinions remain divided — with some defending the companies' business decisions and others demanding better artist protections — the dominant fan sentiment calls for greater transparency and respect for creative origins. Bunnies and neutral observers urge HYBE and ADOR to address root issues constructively rather than through prolonged litigation that sidelines young talents.
NewJeans' influence on modern K-pop remains undeniable, as even major publications have noted their cultural impact despite the hiatus. Whether this anniversary serves as a turning point toward resolution or further division remains to be seen. Fans continue to voice hopes that the members can return to making music on their terms, free from perceived corporate interference that many believe has hindered their trajectory.
As the K-pop industry evolves, cases like this underscore the need for clearer boundaries on creative rights and artist agency — issues that extend far beyond any single group or label.